The Lost Synagogues of Detroit » AARON ISRAEL [STOLINER SHUL]
Author Message

Lowell (admin)
Board Administrator
Username: admin

Post Number: 92
Registered: 1-2004
Posted From:
Posted on Thursday, May 12, 2005 - 3:00 pm

The following memories were previously contributed by email. To add your memories simply scroll to the bottom where you will find the "Add Your Message Here" posting box. Write your message, put any name you wish in the username box and click Preview/Post Message. [No password needed]


I have just spent more than an enjoyable, albeit sad, morning viewing the "ruins" of Detroit. Then I discover more gold - your "lost synagogues" of Detroit page.

I'm in my early 40s and live in Windsor. My mother was born and grew up in Detroit in the Linwood/Gladstone Jewish neighbourhood in the 30s and 40s.

My late father Michael was one of less than a handful of survivors of the massacre of more than 7,000 Jews of the Stolin, Belarus ghetto on Rosh Hashana, 1942. He was the only survivor, that I know of, who lived by actually hiding within the ghetto itself. The other ghetto Jews - mostly women, children and elderly, were from Stolin and the neighbouring villages of David Horodok and Rubel. The Jewish men of these villages and towns mostly were massacred in 1941.

My father, when he was dating my mother, just loved the Linwood area and felt totally at home there. He said it reminded him of pre-war Jewish Poland, with so many shules and Yiddish in all the shop windows.

I've tried, in vain, to take my mother over the river to scout out her old neighbourhood. She's 78 now and nervous.

I've also spent considerable time researching Stolin (now in Belarus), the home of my family for at least 300 years until the Holocaust. I was very pleased to see the Stoliner shule of Detroit and your link to Avram Shacham's wonderful web site of his trip to Stolin.

Since Mr. Schacham's visit to Stolin a few years ago, there have been many great changes occurring in Stolin. For the first time since the massacre of the Stolin ghetto Jews in the forest of Stasino, a Yizkor - or Memory Day - service was held in 2000 and will again take place this year on September 23rd.

A person by the name of Michael Chernyavski - not a Stoliner - but a Russian Jew who now lives in Stolin, has taken it upon himself to clean up the White Shule. His efforts attracted attention as no one had done this in 58 years - as 400 years of Stoliner Jewry was totally wiped out in 1942.

Little by little, local people came forward, telling Mr. Chernyavski of their Jewish roots - something no one would offer previously, based on the murder of the Jews and the persecution of any others during the Soviet regime.

They formed a small Jewish Community two years ago - a miracle to say the least. They went into the forest and cleaned up the grave, reburied bones and cleaned up broken liquor bottles. Apparently the mass grave was a popular site for youths over the years who would dig up bones and drink there - they know nothing of what happened - if you can believe that. They have their myths that the Jews were buried with gold and diamonds. In reality they were human skeletons and broken souls when they were shot at the brink of the pits they dug themselves.

There is now a proper Hebrew/Belarussian grave marker there as well.

Although Stolin had a great Jewish history and sparked the Karliner-Stolin hassidim sect, the little Jewish community of Stolin today has absolutely no archives, pictures or anything else. Your picture of the Detroit shule, with your permission, would be welcome to them.

I am going to Stolin for this year's Rosh Hashana Memorial Service. My grandparents, aunts, cousins and countless other relatives are all buried in the forest. My father, who passed away in 1984, forbid me to ever go there as much of the killing and misery was conducted by the local people.

I hope he forgives me, but I just have to see it for myself and say the Kaddish prayer in the forest.

It was a beautiful Jewish world there - just as once was the Linwood area.

It's ironic, but the Jewish worlds of both my parents - Detroit and Stolin - are gone.

Thank you for your wonderful website.
I have just spent more than an enjoyable, albeit sad, morning viewing the "ruins" of Detroit.
- Murray N.

There is some very interesting history with Stolin and Detroit. A Stoliner group of Chassidim lived here and established that old 'shul' on Elmhurst in Detroit. The Chassidim were led by a "Rebbe" who immigrated from Europe and settled in New York City. He came to Detroit periodically to visit his 'Chassidim'. On one visit (in the '50's?) he passed away. The Chassidim wanted to move his remains back to New York for the funeral and burial. However, when they went through his belongings they discovered that the Stoliner Rebbe had taken along shrouds on this trip and left a note that he wanted to be buried in Detroit. Since that time, a large group of Stoliner Chassidim come every year on the Rebbe's Yahrzheit (date of passing) to visit his grave, pray, sing and learn to honor his memory.
- Miriam

Speaking as a Stoliner chossid myself, I wish to let you know that our shuls have often been called Bais Aaron v'Yisroel. I doubt it was called "Aaron Israel." We have had a few Rebbes named Reb Aharon, and one named Reb Yisroel, and that is why we often use that combination of names. "Aaron v'Yisroel" means "Aaron and Yisroel," which in English is "Aaron and Israel." I could find out the name of the Detroit shul for sure, by asking around here where I daaven (pray), in the Brooklyn Stoliner Shul, which happens to be called Bais Aaron v'Yisroel. Where did you get those amazing pictures of our shul in Stolin? Thanks much!
- Mordechai

This structure looks like the "Stoliner Shteibel" that I remember as a child growing up near the corner of Elmhurst and Davison(?). What about the Young Israel Synagogue, and the Mogen Avrohom on Dexter near Cortland? This is a fascinating study...good luck! Have you seen Irwin Cohen's history of Jewish Detroit for background on some of these structures?
- Miriam

Miriam is correct, this was the Stoliner Shul or the Elmhurst Street Shul.

The formal name of the synagogue was Aaron Israel but it was called the Stoliner Shul because the people who founded the synagogue came from the town of Stolin and were followers of the Stoliner Rebbe.

The building on the other corner (NW) did indeed house the 2 congregations and the Yeshiva Chachmey Lublin.
- Ruthe

A person on your email site refers to the Stoliner Rebbe. He died just after Pesach in 1946 at my grandmother's house on Elmhurst. My grandmother's name was Eva Hoberman Wainer.

I publish a Wainer/Hoberman Newsletter. These people's families lived in Stolin before the holocaust and I would like to print these rememberances in the holiday newsletter. I have tried to copy/paste the information from the site, but have been unsuccessful.

-- Judy Goldis

[try copy and paste now, it will work - Lowell]

Z Millman (Unregistered Guest)
Permitted by Moderator
Posted From:
Posted on Friday, June 03, 2005 - 4:29 pm

Are any of the members of the Stoliner shul, who came from Stolin, still alive? My father's family came from Stolin and I am trying to find information.

thank you

Z Millman

(Message approved by admin)

Allan Katz (Unregistered Guest)
Permitted by Moderator
Posted From:
Posted on Tuesday, November 01, 2005 - 12:20 pm

I was shocked and surprised to find this lovely picture! Thanks for posting!
My grandfather Hyman Katz was a member, and I was at his side on High Holidays on many occasions. He always sat at the far end near the rear. The altar was in the center to the left side of the building. I estimate it could seat about 150-200 men. Women sat upstairs behind a ritual screen. My grandmother occasionally attended and I once visited her in the balcony and wondered why this was done. To the right of the building in the basement there was a ritual bath. I believe the entrance was on the side. The shul was stricly Orthodox and it was attended by very religious men.
Allan Katz
Napa, CA

(Message approved by admin)

LarisaChaya Kunina (Unregistered Guest)
Permitted by Moderator
Posted From:
Posted on Sunday, November 06, 2005 - 7:33 pm

I am looking for people who know names Efraim Aron Frenkel(1858-1930),his father-in-law Samson (Shimshon)Melamed,his wife Miriam Frenkel(Melamed), his nephew Moshe Melamed. All of them from Stolin.
I will appreciate any information.

(Message approved by admin)

Michael (Unregistered Guest)
Permitted by Moderator
Posted From:
Posted on Monday, July 02, 2007 - 9:21 pm

My family belonged to the Stoliner shul when we lived on Elmhurst (just west of Dexter) in the 1940's and 50's. I had my bar mitzvah at the Stoliner in June, 1954. The invitation listed the shul as "Congregation Beth Aaron V'Israel." As I recall, no English was spoken at all during the service; anything not in Hebrew was announced in Yiddish. I attended many holiday services with my father (Frank Olinick) and grandfather (Sam Cohen)
and have many fond memories.

(Message approved by admin)

Chava (Unregistered Guest)
Permitted by Moderator
Posted From:
Posted on Thursday, April 10, 2008 - 7:35 pm

This Stoliner shul was established as the Jewish community moved Northwest into the Linwood area. There were previous Stoliner shules in the older neighborhoods which preceeded this shul. One of them you show here as Beth Aaron V'Israel at 9550 Oakland. Beth Aharon V'Yisroel is the name of Stoliner Shules, named after two of the Stoliner Rebbes. It is interesting to note that this Stoliner Shul was one of the very last to keep its doors open in the Linwood - Dexter neighborhood.

I come from a Stoliner family and grew up in this shul. I know every nook and cranny of the shul and have such beautiful memories of my childhood years there.

For those of you who are not aware there is a thriving active Stoliner community in Brooklyn New York and an ever larger one in Israel, complete with vibrant shules.

Once a year on the the 6th day of the Hebrew month of Iyar, which is the yahrzeit (anniversary of the death) of the Stoliner Rebbe, Reb Yankele z'tzl. Reb Yankele z'tzl passed away during one of his visits to his chassidim in Detroit and is buiried in the Stoliner cemetary which is adjacent to the Chessed Shel Emes (Hebrew Memorial Park) on Gratiot Avenue and 14 Mile Road in Clinton Township. On that day each year many Stoliner chassidim both from Israel and New York come to Detroit together with the present Rebbe Shlita Rabbi Baruch Sochet (who lives in Isrel) to observe the yahrzeit of Reb Yankele z'tzal. This tradition has been ongoin for more than fifty years since the Rebbe passed away. The gathering is open to the public and is usually held in Congregation Dovid Ben Nochum on Lincoln just East of Greenfield in Oak Park.

(Message approved by admin)